Go to Post If you use a flux capacitor make certain it is a COTS component, or that you fabricate it from COTS materials. - Richard Wallace [more]
Home
Go Back   Chief Delphi > CD-Media > Photos
CD-Media   CD-Spy  
portal register members calendar search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read FAQ rules

photos

papers

everything



Histogram of Week 2 OPR

By: Ian Curtis
New: 12-03-2011 15:24
Updated: 13-03-2011 15:58
Views: 1960 times


Histogram of Week 2 OPR

[EDIT]Please scroll down to see the updated histogram, this one is missing the Michigan events and NYC![/EDIT]

Above is a histogram (bar graph) of OPR at the end of qualifying rounds on Saturday of week 2 in 2011. OPR is a statistic based on which teams a team plays with, and their cumulative alliance scores. Here is the mathematical description. It is a rough estimate of the number of points a given robot is "worth" per match. Negative scores may be the result of frequent penalties, or the algorithm "overcompensating" if a good team has a bad match. It is far from a perfect system. The average OPR during week 2 was 9.16 points, which is slightly higher than week 1's 8.77 points.

I used Bongle's excellent OPRnet program.

Cumulative Distribution for Week 1
Cumulative Distribution for Week 2

Recent Viewers

  • Guest

Discussion

view entire thread

Reply

13-03-2011 09:46

IKE


Unread Re: pic: Histogram of Week 2 OPR

Nice figure. What are the total number of teams that have competed so far?



13-03-2011 12:29

dodar


Unread Re: pic: Histogram of Week 2 OPR

You should parallel those guys from team 340 and do a top 25 from OPR.



13-03-2011 12:38

Ian Curtis


Unread Re: pic: Histogram of Week 2 OPR

Quote:
Originally Posted by IKE View Post
Nice figure. What are the total number of teams that have competed so far?
There are 340 teams that played in Week 2, and 220 teams that played in Week 1. This double counts the teams that played both weeks though (but I don't believe there were many).



13-03-2011 12:40

dodar


Unread Re: pic: Histogram of Week 2 OPR

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ian Curtis View Post
There are 340 teams that played in Week 2, and 220 teams that played in Week 1. This double counts the teams that played both weeks though (but I don't believe there were many).
According to my FRC Spyder app for Android, there were 449 teams competing in week 2 events and week 1 had 301 teams compete.



13-03-2011 12:51

Barry Bonzack


Unread Re: pic: Histogram of Week 2 OPR

I wouldn't mind knowing what the average OPR is for all teams in the eliminations



13-03-2011 14:12

Ian Curtis


Unread Re: pic: Histogram of Week 2 OPR

Quote:
Originally Posted by dodar View Post
According to my FRC Spyder app for Android, there were 449 teams competing in week 2 events and week 1 had 301 teams compete.
Hmmm... That's a big error! I must have missed some events.

Week 2 I didn't include NYC, as they still had qualifying matches to play when I did this. It seems like I'd still need another week 2 event and then 2 week 1 events to make up the difference. I'm not a programming guy, so I just went down the list of events and and copied the results into Excel and then ran it through some MATLAB scripts. I'll check back.

OPR isn't a great thing to compare teams across regionals. Better than nothing, (it certainly is very good at indicating who the fantastic robots are) but once you get into the pack of teams it can be hard to compare.

1114 came out swinging as the first team to break 60 though, and Wildstang was just behind them in the very high 50s.

Barry,

I can do that, give me a day or two. Anecdotally, at WPI the top two alliances were around 60 (for the entire alliance combined), most were around 45, and then the lowest two were around 30. That would indicate a "rough" average of about 15. At every event I've looked at, the ACs and first round picks are typically all fall within the top 20 by OPR. The 2nd round picks typically go deeper into the field, but I've yet to see a team with negative OPR get picked (perhaps it does do a decent job at predicting penalties?). Just going off of WPI I'd say that something like 20 of the top 24 by OPR made eliminations. My numbers aren't in front of me at the moment though, so I'll check that too.

At WPI (which is the event I was concentrating on) the average OPR of a robot in the elimination rounds was 15. 2 alliances had a cumulative OPR of over 60, two had an OPR of about 45 and the remainder were between 40-30, with one 25. The top 16 robots by OPR were also the Alliance Captains and first round picks. Of the 24 teams who played Saturday afternoon, 21 of them were in the top 24 by OPR. While OPR didn't do a very good job of actually predicting match scores, the alliance with the highest OPR won every matchup.

[EDIT] Mike, does that 449 include Israel? I did not include them either as they have yet to play.[/EDIT]
[EDIT2]Revised by elimination OPR statements after checking my notes[/EDIT2]



13-03-2011 14:17

dodar


Unread Re: pic: Histogram of Week 2 OPR

No, FRC Spyder considers Israel week 3.



13-03-2011 14:22

Vikesrock


Unread Re: pic: Histogram of Week 2 OPR

If you are missing 2 events week 1 and 1 event week 2 perhaps you are missing the Michigan districts?

Week 1
Kettering - GG
Traverse City - GT

Week 2
Waterford - OC1



13-03-2011 15:29

Ian Curtis


Unread Re: pic: Histogram of Week 2 OPR

Thanks Kevin, I was missing the Michigan Events!



This new graph should include all week 2 events, including the New York City Regional and the Waterford District.

I now show 444 teams competed at week 2, which is still not quite exactly 449. The actual mean week 2 OPR was 8.35, and the Median OPR was 4.9. The 1st quartile was .407 points, and the third quartile was 12.87 points.

Updating the week 1 statistics, we find that actual mean for week 1 OPR was 8.214, and the median was 4.61. The first quartile was .413, the third quartile was 13.815. I show 298 teams competed, which is again slightly off from 301.



view entire thread

Reply
previous
next

Tags

loading ...



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:27.

The Chief Delphi Forums are sponsored by Innovation First International, Inc.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi