05-03-2014 11:55

alexander.h

Re: pic: Team 25 - Evil Machine 12.0 AKA Catch-25

Were you cautioned or warned about your net by the refs or the inspection team? We also have a net and we're thinking if we should cover it up with something (like, for example, a transparent shower curtain) so that the other robots wouldn't get tangled in it.

05-03-2014 12:16

thefro526

Re: pic: Team 25 - Evil Machine 12.0 AKA Catch-25

We had the pleasure of playing against 25 this past weekend, and their net is actually really, really well thought out when looking at the entanglement risk. I'm not sure if they were hassled by the refs or inspectors at all, but I wasn't the least bit worried about getting stuck in their net. In the starting configuration, and pretty much any time when they're not catching, the net stores well inside the frame perimeter and is pretty tight and out of the way. Once the net is out, it's pretty high off the ground, meaning that a lot of robots actually can go right under it.

I'll admit that I was skeptical of this robot at the beginning, but it's starting to grow on me.

05-03-2014 12:20

alexander.h

Re: pic: Team 25 - Evil Machine 12.0 AKA Catch-25

I see ... But our net is 20 cm off the ground, always extended outside the frame perimeter, dangling, and kind of loose.

05-03-2014 12:30

EricH

Re: pic: Team 25 - Evil Machine 12.0 AKA Catch-25

20 centimeters? 8" off the ground? And I assume that you start with it inside the frame perimeter and let it drop...

I suggest tightening that net up, a lot, as soon as you can, including figuring out a way to bring it inside the frame perimeter whenever you want to. It's probably going to be an entangling magnet. Considering that just about every robot out there is taller than its bumpers, you're asking for trouble.


On the other hand, this is also going to depend a bit on the inspectors and refs. After the first entanglement call, you're probably going to be back at inspection until it's fixed.

05-03-2014 12:35

alexander.h

Re: pic: Team 25 - Evil Machine 12.0 AKA Catch-25

Exactly, we let it drop in the beginning of the match, but we don't have time to make a mechanism to reel it back in. Do you think that it would help to put a transparent sheet of something to cover the net (so that the net is still functional, it doesn't tangle the robots nor does it block the view of drivers)?

05-03-2014 12:57

EricH

Re: pic: Team 25 - Evil Machine 12.0 AKA Catch-25

You're going to need to do something. Otherwise, you'll be either entangling or getting damaged just about every match, probably both. A transparent sheet of something might help; a pretty fine mesh would be an excellent option (less chance of tangling unless you've taken damage). I would also suggest coming up with a way of pulling in the netting supports at least partially to get them farther out of the way (and avoid penalties).

05-03-2014 13:01

alexander.h

Re: pic: Team 25 - Evil Machine 12.0 AKA Catch-25

Like I said, we can cover up the net, but we do not have anytime whatsoever to design and build a mechanism to bring in the net.

05-03-2014 13:05

Kevin Leonard

Re: pic: Team 25 - Evil Machine 12.0 AKA Catch-25

What a fantastic catcher. I love that a well-known team like 25 decided to go with this bold design.
You guys are on my "watch" list for 2014.

05-03-2014 13:18

AlecMataloni

Re: pic: Team 25 - Evil Machine 12.0 AKA Catch-25

At the beginning of the season, I knew that a robot with awesome catching and inbounding ability would be the ultimate utility robot, and i hoped that somebody would build this robot. You'll be playing after lunch on saturday in st. louis for sure.

05-03-2014 13:31

Akash Rastogi

Re: pic: Team 25 - Evil Machine 12.0 AKA Catch-25

I, too, will admit that I was skeptical when Shaun first showed me video of this bot. 25's execution during their matches was great though. Definitely a nice recovery from the 2013 season. Hope to play you guys at MAR Champs and 2495 will see you at Lenape!

05-03-2014 21:46

DonRotolo

Re: pic: Team 25 - Evil Machine 12.0 AKA Catch-25

You may have to weight your ability to catch with a net against the penalty for entanglement. At least one team was warned by their inspector that their net was an entanglement hazard. Thankfully for them it never happened.

06-03-2014 12:03

mc153

Re: pic: Team 25 - Evil Machine 12.0 AKA Catch-25

I don't have anything technical to say so I'm just gonna go for it...

06-03-2014 19:04

JesseK

Re: pic: Team 25 - Evil Machine 12.0 AKA Catch-25

Nice to see someone else with a similar style intake (folds out and can kick the ball). Even has the same green wheels

Seriously sweet catch.