Go to Post Sleep well Chief Delphi, because for the next 6 weeks, sleep is only for the weak. :D - ttldomination [more]
Home
Go Back   Chief Delphi > CD-Media > Photos
CD-Media   CD-Spy  
portal register members calendar search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read FAQ rules

photos

papers

everything



Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

Elgin Clock

By: Elgin Clock
New: 01-03-2015 22:53
Updated: 01-03-2015 22:53
Views: 1573 times


Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

Finals match 2 at the 2015 Waterbury District Event in CT.
Our alliance (blue) thought we had been defeated based on the real-time scores until a really long pause after the match by the Referees scoring the match.
We assumed they just wanted to delay the outcome to keep us on our toes, but they were actually calculating all the Litter scored. For everyone who doesn't think Litter can be a factor, you've never seen amazing human players like Team 4557's and ours (Team 237) working together.

The Finals 2 match Litter score pushed it to 3 matches, and we eventually lost in the 3rd but the amount of energy as this screen went up was AMAZING to witness!!

Recent Viewers

  • Guest

Discussion

view entire thread

Reply

01-03-2015 23:34

ThunderousPrime


Unread Re: pic: Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

You can say that again.
(Litter was the difference.)





01-03-2015 23:42

rich2202


Unread Re: pic: Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

In the first game of the finals at Lake Superior Regional, the score was 100 to 101. The winning alliance was able to move one Litter to the landfill in the last few seconds. Without the move, the other alliance would have won 104 to 100.



01-03-2015 23:48

Boltman


Unread Re: pic: Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

I'm preparing our team to throw litter as needed in weeks 5 and 6 hopefully by then litter throwing will NOT be a factor as is it "grey's" competition ..but be prepared anyhow! A good team should not need throw any litter to win IMO. But IF challenged should respond in kind..as in being prepared.



02-03-2015 00:02

PayneTrain


Unread Re: pic: Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

Great robot play 10/10



02-03-2015 00:04

EricH


Unread Re: pic: Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

Had a similar result in Inland Empire, red won barely before blue litter was factored in. F-2 swung on this.



02-03-2015 00:12

WeJohnFriedIt


Unread Re: pic: Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

On a related note, our human player got all 10 noodles across for a perfect 40 points during the quarterfinals of the Georgia Southern Classic Regional. Without that perfect game, we wouldn't have advanced to the semifinals. Has anyone else seen all 10 thrown successfully across?



02-03-2015 00:18

ThunderousPrime


Unread Re: pic: Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

Quote:
Originally Posted by WeJohnFriedIt View Post
On a related note, our human player got all 10 noodles across for a perfect 40 points during the quarterfinals of the Georgia Southern Classic Regional. Without that perfect game, we wouldn't have advanced to the semifinals. Has anyone else seen all 10 thrown successfully across?
1836's HP has done it. I didn't see it myself but I was told by their coach who saw it himself.



02-03-2015 00:22

EricH


Unread Re: pic: Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

Quote:
Originally Posted by ThunderousPrime View Post
1836's HP has done it. I didn't see it myself but I was told by their coach who saw it himself.
I didn't see it either--but it wouldn't surprise me. That kid can throw! 50% was a bad match for him--7-8 was typical.



02-03-2015 00:49

Abrakadabra


Unread Re: pic: Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

Correct me if I'm wrong, but I believe the "Litter" score shown on the scoreboard also includes the 6 pts for each litter placed in an RC, no?
My point being that sometimes those high litter scores you see are not due to accurate throwers, but rather to teams going for maximum points by placing the litter where (IMHO) it really belongs.



02-03-2015 00:57

IronicDeadBird


Unread Re: pic: Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

I really feel like that litter shouldn't be worth so much but it is what it is.
I also really don't like that one of the core mechanics of this game is promoting throwing trash into your competitions work space, that is just rude.



02-03-2015 02:19

asid61


Unread Re: pic: Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

Quote:
Originally Posted by Abrakadabra View Post
teams going for maximum points by placing the litter where (IMHO) it really belongs.
Quote:
Originally Posted by IronicDeadBird View Post
I also really don't like that one of the core mechanics of this game is promoting throwing trash into your competitions work space, that is just rude.
I feel like the puns this year are out of control.



02-03-2015 02:24

StAxis


Unread Re: pic: Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

I would love for the GDC to adjust the litter points to 2 or 3 for thrown. While they are impressive to score and should be valuable, I don't think they should be valued about equal to the maximum you can get with a stack, it makes seeding matches just that more wonky with co-op thrown in. I really didn't expect to see the level of noodle throwing we saw at Georgia though, 1466 was an absolute noodle machine.



02-03-2015 03:32

Jared Russell


Unread Re: pic: Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

Quote:
Originally Posted by StAxis View Post
I would love for the GDC to adjust the litter points to 2 or 3 for thrown. While they are impressive to score and should be valuable, I don't think they should be valued about equal to the maximum you can get with a stack, it makes seeding matches just that more wonky with co-op thrown in. I really didn't expect to see the level of noodle throwing we saw at Georgia though, 1466 was an absolute noodle machine.
I don't think changing point values fixes anything. Even if they made all litter not in cans worth zero points, in elims you ought to throw them across just to make your opponents' match more difficult. A lucky throw can make your opponent waste tons of time - or even knock them out for the rest of the match if it ends up in a drivetrain or mechanism.



02-03-2015 10:45

Daniel_LaFleur


Unread Re: pic: Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

Quote:
Originally Posted by WeJohnFriedIt View Post
On a related note, our human player got all 10 noodles across for a perfect 40 points during the quarterfinals of the Georgia Southern Classic Regional. Without that perfect game, we wouldn't have advanced to the semifinals. Has anyone else seen all 10 thrown successfully across?
Your human player was just ridiculously good. Ours was good but yours was just crazy good.



02-03-2015 10:51

WeJohnFriedIt


Unread Re: pic: Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

Thanks! We were worried because he actually injured his knee shortly before the competition, but his practice throughout the season paid off anyways.



02-03-2015 10:59

Shrub


Unread Re: pic: Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

Quote:
Originally Posted by EricH View Post
I didn't see it either--but it wouldn't surprise me. That kid can throw! 50% was a bad match for him--7-8 was typical.
Nicollet FEAR was amazing at this. Seeing the first few matches played, noodles did play a huge part of the game until robots were able to create a strategy that worked for them and their alliance. After that, teleop/coopertition did end up counting more than noodles. I didn't see Auto do too much to scoring compared to last year.



02-03-2015 12:11

rich2202


Unread Re: pic: Litter scoring affects match outcomes!

Quote:
Originally Posted by IronicDeadBird View Post
I really feel like that litter shouldn't be worth so much but it is what it is.
I also really don't like that one of the core mechanics of this game is promoting throwing trash into your competitions work space, that is just rude.
The purpose of the game was to encourage recycling and care of the environment.

The unintended consequences are that it encourages a team to litter to score points, and to muck up the other field to keep the other side from scoring points. Not a message you want to teach the kids - beneficial to litter.



view entire thread

Reply
previous
next

Tags

loading ...



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:31.

The Chief Delphi Forums are sponsored by Innovation First International, Inc.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi