18-04-2016 15:56

trumpthero786

Re: pic: Would you say this is in or not?

Hmm. This is a tricky one, but the manual (1.5.3) says that

"Climbers Inside an Alliance-specific Shelter earn ten points per Climber for their Alliance."

I would unfortunately not give this as a score as the Climber is not inside the shelter, but rather on it. I always give benefit of the doubt, as any ref would, but I don't think this is a situation where that applies. What did the refs call it as?

18-04-2016 15:58

orangemoore

Re: pic: Would you say this is in or not?

Quote:

Originally Posted by trumpthero786 Hmm. This is a tricky one, but the manual (1.5.3) says that "Climbers Inside an Alliance-specific Shelter earn ten points per Climber for their Alliance." I would unfortunately not give this as a score as the Climber is not inside the shelter, but rather on it. I always give benefit of the doubt, as any ref would, but I don't think this is a situation where that applies. What did the refs call it as?

19-04-2016 13:22

2021eruf

Re: pic: Would you say this is in or not?

Quote:

Originally Posted by trumpthero786 Hmm. This is a tricky one, but the manual (1.5.3) says that "Climbers Inside an Alliance-specific Shelter earn ten points per Climber for their Alliance." I would unfortunately not give this as a score as the Climber is not inside the shelter, but rather on it. I always give benefit of the doubt, as any ref would, but I don't think this is a situation where that applies. What did the refs call it as?

19-04-2016 15:26

trumpthero786

Re: pic: Would you say this is in or not?

Oh wow I didn't even take a second look at the PVC frame and multicolored tiles I can't believe I missed that!

19-04-2016 15:32

tvb999

Re: pic: Would you say this is in or not?

By Forum Post #123, that would count as in:

"Sections 1.5.2.2 and 1.5.3.3 of the Game Manual Part 2 state that Climbers Inside an Alliance-specific Shelter earn ten points per Climber. In the context of the game FIRST RES-Q, an object that has crossed into the vertical extension of a defined Area's boundary is "Inside" the Area. A Climber that is resting on the top edges of the Shelter Goal should be counted as Scored if any portion of the Climber crosses into the vertical extension of the Shelter Goal's side walls. The Climber does not have to break through the horizontal plane of the rectangular opening of the Shelter Goal in order to be counted as Scored."

19-04-2016 19:57

trumpthero786

Re: pic: Would you say this is in or not?

Quote:

Originally Posted by tvb999 By Forum Post #123, that would count as in: "Sections 1.5.2.2 and 1.5.3.3 of the Game Manual Part 2 state that Climbers Inside an Alliance-specific Shelter earn ten points per Climber. In the context of the game FIRST RES-Q, an object that has crossed into the vertical extension of a defined Area's boundary is "Inside" the Area. A Climber that is resting on the top edges of the Shelter Goal should be counted as Scored if any portion of the Climber crosses into the vertical extension of the Shelter Goal's side walls. The Climber does not have to break through the horizontal plane of the rectangular opening of the Shelter Goal in order to be counted as Scored."