I stated my opinion. I don’t think it’s fair to criticise me for “shooting my mouth off” when a forum is literally a place for public discussion and debate. I respect your, and everyone else’s, right to voice their opinion, whatever it may be. I think you should respect mine as well.
I never said or suggested that they were incompetent. I pointed out that I believed there were two teams available who, in my opinion, were better choices, which has nothing to do with being competent or incompetent. In fact, I did not discuss 5478’s play at all, so I’m struggling to see how I’m implying that 5478 is incompetent. On the other hand, I would contend that you passing off 5531’s defence as “antics” and suggesting that it was dirty and unsportsmanlike implies that 5531 is incompetent more than I imply that 5478 is incompetent. But that’s neither here nor there.
Onto the actual topic. You are correct that 5478 was one of the best, if not the best, defensive robots. However, I would question the impact that defence had.
In the semifinals, alliance 2 managed to score 6-7 cargo in each match. That’s 1.3 less cargo on average scored than in alliance 2’s quarterfinal match-up. So, the defence had some impact. It is of note, though, that 5531, a relatively good cargo scorer, focused on cargo in quarterfinals, but on defence in semifinals, so the lower cargo score is also reflective of that.
In finals, alliance 2 scored 6 cargo in the first match, and only 4 in the second match, where 94 prevented them from scoring on an entire side of the cargo ship after sandstorm. That’s 2.5 less cargo than alliance 2 scored in quarterfinals, with the same note as in the semifinals.
I understand that each match has its own context, and perhaps in a vacuum, 5478 is a better defender than 94. However, the fact remains that 94 had a level 2 climb, which would have given alliance 3 access to 3 extra points that alliances 1 and 2 could not possibly get. The question is if the defensive advantage 5478 has over 94 compensates for the lack of a level 2 climb, and I think it does not.
Again, this is only my opinion, and you are free to have yours. Let’s agree to disagree, and not get personal over something like this.