Another hypothetical district - New York 2019

Well, the equivalent CA and MN threads seem to be active, so here’s New York.

In 2019, 172 teams from New York state competed across 11 regional events, 7 of which local to our state. Moving to districts would be a minimum of 9 district events, but likely wind up at 9-12 due to the clustering of teams around the state.

As for DCMP sizes, we would likely have either a 64 team DCMP or a 2 40-division team DCMP. We are realistically big enough to support either. Ontario has the same number of active teams (172).

Here is a list of district standings. Ev1 is event 1, Ev2 is event 2. Age is the age bonus given (10 for rookies, 5 for second-year teams). DCMP? denotes whether or not a team would have qualified in the 64 team DCMP. CMP denotes whether or not the team actually qualified for champs in 2019 via the regional model.

If a team attended only one event, I simply doubled their points. Not a perfect indicator, but it’s fine for hypotheticals. Tiebreakers are not implemented here.

  #    Team    Ev1    Ev2    Age    Tot  DCMP?    CMP
---  ------  -----  -----  -----  -----  -------  -----
  1      20     73     73      0    146  y        y
  2    2791     72     73      0    145  y        y
  3     870     73     70      0    143  y        y
  4    1796     72     70      0    142  y        y
  5    3015     66     62      0    128  y        y
  6     694     60     61      0    121  y        y
  7     340     55     63      0    118  y        y
  8    1493     58     58      0    116  y        y
  9    2638     37     76      0    113  y        y
 10    3003     59     48      0    107  y        y
 11    1468     65     38      0    103  y        y
 12    7651     45     45     10    100  y        y
 13    4930     53     46      0     99  y        y
 14    5254     49     47      0     96  y
 15    1511     58     32      0     90  y
 16    4122     28     61      0     89  y        y
 17     329     41     45      0     86  y        y
 18    3157     47     39      0     86  y
 19    2161     42     42      0     84  y
 20    4571     42     40      0     82  y
 21     250     36     42      0     78  y        y
 22     271     36     40      0     76  y        y
 23     287     29     47      0     76  y
 24    1551     29     46      0     75  y
 25     229     54     20      0     74  y        y
 26    6401     43     31      0     74  y        y
 27    1155     17     56      0     73  y        y
 28    1880     30     43      0     73  y
 29    7030     34     34      5     73  y
 30     333     29     43      0     72  y
 31    3173     24     48      0     72  y
 32    6880     23     43      5     71  y
 33    3044     26     44      0     70  y        y
 34    7504     30     30     10     70  y
 35     145     36     33      0     69  y
 36     639     44     25      0     69  y
 37    1507     39     30      0     69  y
 38    3624     28     41      0     69  y        y
 39    2265     22     45      0     67  y        y
 40    1405     20     45      0     65  y
 41    7251     30     30      5     65  y
 42     354     23     41      0     64  y
 43    2228     35     29      0     64  y
 44    6806     17     41      5     63  y        y
 45     334     28     32      0     60  y
 46     395     35     25      0     60  y        y
 47     810     22     38      0     60  y
 48    2053     30     30      0     60  y
 49    2347     30     30      0     60  y
 50    3171     32     28      0     60  y
 51    2869     22     37      0     59  y        y
 52    6911     45      8      5     58  y        y
 53    6868     26     26      5     57  y
 54    1450     28     28      0     56  y
 55    1546     28     28      0     56  y
 56    6300     30     26      0     56  y
 57    5585     27     27      0     54  y        y
 58     514     32     21      0     53  y
 59     353     26     26      0     52  y        y
 60     263     17     33      0     50  y        y
 61     527     15     35      0     50  y
 62    2027     25     25      0     50  y
 63    5964     25     25      0     50
 64     358     20     29      0     49
 65    2601     29     20      0     49
 66    7031     22     22      5     49
 67    4567     24     24      0     48
 68    6593     24     24      0     48
 69    1660     10     37      0     47  y        y
 70     191     23     23      0     46           y
 71     871     18     28      0     46
 72    1635     23     23      0     46
 73    2579      8     38      0     46
 74    4006     23     23      0     46
 75     378     27     18      0     45
 76    1126     25     20      0     45
 77    2875     34     11      0     45
 78    5943     30     15      0     45           y
 79    5016     25     19      0     44
 80    5736     17     27      0     44
 81    6870     15     24      5     44
 82    7004      9     30      5     44
 83     564     17     25      0     42  y        y
 84    2344     21     21      0     42
 85    2872     15     27      0     42
 86    3419     16     26      0     42
 87    1559     23     18      0     41
 88    5659      6     35      0     41
 89     569     19     19      0     38
 90    1591     19     19      0     38
 91     578     11     26      0     37
 92     533      7     29      0     36
 93    4458      6     30      0     36
 94    7400     13     13     10     36           y
 95      28      6     29      0     35
 96    5030     25     10      0     35
 97    1665     10     24      0     34
 98    4383     17     17      0     34
 99    6463     17     17      0     34
100    6746     17     17      0     34
101    7730     12     12     10     34
102    7036     14     14      5     33
103    7318     14     14      5     33
104     352     16     16      0     32
105    3838     16     16      0     32
106    7668     11     11     10     32
107    6969     15     11      5     31
108    5806     14     16      0     30
109    7718      4     16     10     30
110    4640     14     14      0     28
111    5421     14     14      0     28
112    6423     14     14      0     28
113    6490     14     14      0     28
114    7759      9      9     10     28
115     806     13     13      0     26
116    1600     13     13      0     26
117    4299     13     13      0     26
118    6422     13     13      0     26
119    3799     15     10      0     25
120     640     12     12      0     24
121    1518      8     16      0     24
122    4093     12     12      0     24
123    4263     12     12      0     24
124    5298      8     16      0     24
125    5590     12     12      0     24
126    5599     14     10      0     24
127    6873      9      9      5     23
128    7272      9      9      5     23
129    1601     11     11      0     22
130    3950     12     10      0     22
131    5123     11     11      0     22
132    6195     11     11      0     22
133    6636     12     10      0     22
134    7027      8      8      5     21
135    1537     10     10      0     20
136    3137     10     10      0     20
137    3204     10     10      0     20
138    5202      5     15      0     20
139    6892      7      7      5     19
140    7016      7      7      5     19
141     335      9      9      0     18
142     884      9      9      0     18
143    1585      9      9      0     18
144    1803      9      9      0     18
145    2895      9      9      0     18
146    6484      9      9      0     18
147     601      8      8      0     16
148    1230      8      8      0     16
149    2487      8      8      0     16
150    3181      8      8      0     16
151    4528      8      8      0     16
152    5149      8      8      0     16
153    6590      8      8      0     16
154    6621      6     10      0     16
155     743      5     10      0     15
156     496      7      7      0     14
157     522      7      7      0     14
158    3017      7      7      0     14
159    4203      7      7      0     14
160    4508      7      7      0     14
161    4773      7      7      0     14
162    2340      4      9      0     13
163     545      6      6      0     12
164    3004      6      6      0     12
165    3760      6      6      0     12
166    3951      6      6      0     12
167    4012      6      6      0     12
168    6648      6      6      0     12
169    5099      5      5      0     10
170    5881      5      5      0     10
171    1554      4      4      0      8
172    1751      4      4      0      8

In a 2 40-team division DCMP, we would additionally invite teams 5964, 358, 2601, 7031, 4567, 6593, 1660, 191, 871, 1635, 2579, 4006, 378, 1126, 2875, 5943, and 5016.

As for world championship qualification via district, pre-DCMP rankings do not necessarily indicate who would qualify for CMP. That said, we would send approximately 29 teams – equal to the amount Ontario sends (since we have the same number of active teams this year). You are free to figure out who you think would qualify.

If you think I’ve made a mistake in point calculations, feel free to point them out.

8 Likes

I thought about doubling the points for single-event teams in the CA thread, but never got around to it. How much did it effect your rankings?

A decent amount. 1493 and 7651 were the big winners there. We had more teams than usual play 2 events this year (notably 3157, 1551), so the effect wasn’t as big. You can click here if you’d like to see rankings where teams do not receive double the points.

1 Like

The trifecta is balanced… as all things should be

2 Likes

Interesting. Follow-up question: is the age bonus supposed to apply once, or per-event? I did per event which I think is correct but I might be wrong.

Is NY in the same spot as California in that we’re perpetually “2 years from moving to Districts?”

Age bonus is once total.

Man. My post was just riddled with problems, apparently.

1 Like

You live and you learn. Took me 30+ tries to get these rankings right, too. :slight_smile:

1 Like

Yup. NY has many of the same obstacles CA does, plus some unique geographic ones. The topic has been beaten to death plenty.

2 Likes

I’d say we are more perpetually 5 years away from districts, rather than 2.

3 Likes

That is true unfortunately.

This topic was automatically closed 365 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.