Champs Alliance Selection
We will be doing some more writeups about our run at the championship, but some people have been asking me about the story of alliance selections on Daly so I thought I would do a writeup on it in here.
Going into the competition we thought that 2056 and 1678 would likely be the class of the division with us and 1796 slightly behind. At moments during the course of the competition 2630 and 9432 showed themselves to be right there with us and 1796. When divisions dropped we set some goals for the competition, we knew we would have a tough time going to Einstein out of this group, and so much would be out of our hands, we just had to do our best and put ourselves in the best possible position that we could. Match schedule would influence a lot, we could only control so much. We set the goal of being the captain or first pick of one of the top 3 alliances. Anything past that would be icing on the cake. Maybe things could break our way and we could make it to Einstein, making division finals would be a real possiblity.
Then our schedule was released…It was an absolute gauntlet. We played really well, and managed to get every non win related ranking point and the coop tiebreaker every match, but we lost 4 matches and finished 9th. 4415 did a fantastic job with not just robot performance, but strategy. They finished first which we knew would create all sorts of interesting possibilities, some of which could break really nicely for us to pair with one of the other top teams (2056, 1678, 1796). Huge credit to 4415, lots of teams get blessed by the match scheduling gods, but following through on seeding first is no easy task when the bright lights of champs are on.
After matches concluded, the pits were filled with whispers and gossip. It was clear that 1678 was going to decline 4415, but it was a question mark if 2056 would decline after 1678 declined. If 2056 accepted, 1796 seemed like they would take us and we would play with our friends from NYC for the 3rd time this season.
4415 came to me and our driver and told us that 1678 was going to decline no matter the iteration of picks and that 2056 would decline no matter the iteration of picks as well. They then informed us that they would likely pick us at that point. 4415 ended up asking 2630 what they would do if chosen, and 2630 said that they would accept.
We discussed this scenario with our head scouts before this and determined that we would accept for a few reasons. First off, 4415, at that point in time, was reasonably high on our picklist and we doubted we would get a better bot if we managed to move up to the 8th or 7th spot. There was also a real, however low it might be, chance that if we declined we would miss playoffs entirely. If 2630 was bluffing about accepting in order to not get scorched and declined and 4655 declined as well we would miss playoffs entirely. With the robot and season we had, I personally felt it was a non starter for us to risk missing playoffs.
I do have regrets about us not talking it over further as a team and I think there were at least a few students who felt that we should have taken the risk. I do think we made the right call, for us, but I think those voices should have been heard out a bit more, before we decided. We told 4415 that we would indeed accept if chosen.
At about 9 on Friday night 4415 called us to let us know they had locked in on picking us after 1678 and 2056 declined. We headed over to their hotel to combine picklists and talk what kind of alliance we wanted to build. We ultimately knew we would be constrained by a few factors in our picking:
- 4415’s side auto just was not consistent or accurate enough, but they did have a center auto that scored their preload and attempted to put 2 in the barge. We needed to pick a team that had a consistent side auto, hopefully a 3 piece.
- Our net scoring was inaccurate and we were unable to pickup from the ground and put the algae in the net. We were able to grab off of the lollipop and score into the barge so we could try strategies around that.
- Our ideal robot had a climb, a side 3 piece, and solid algae scoring. The ground algae pickup wasn’t necessary since 4415 had that ability.
This boxed us in a number of ways in our picking of a second pick and backup bot. We were ultimately thrilled to get 302 and 1425. 4415 is a fantastic team and was a pleasure to work with, our alliance just had the fatal flaw of missing algae and in such a high power division that was something that really sank us in the end. This was overall a really cool experience for our team, and we learned a lot of lessons from it. We hope to see our partners from Daly again in the offseason and on future divisions. This is our second time playing with 4415 at worlds, hopefully the 3rd time will be the charm in a future year!