The Secret City Wildbots tested our next generation shooter this week. We were able to get over 80’ total distance (When the disks hit the ground). When the disks flew past the 54’ mark they were approx. 12’ in the air. We’re using a flywheel design with an 8" wheel being driven by a CIM with a 1:1.2 transmission.
I would suggest that if you are shooting from close to the goal (like in the first two videos) you turn the speed down. They’re going so fast I think they may bounce right back out of the goal (even with the chains to help). We saw this in 2006 where teams would shoot too hard and balls would hit the chains and bounce off.
That’s the next step! Thanks for keeping us on track. Today we added a guard to keep the disk from riding up on the wheel at the end. That way we don’t curve quite as much. We’re also working hard to master encoders and PIDs to monitor the motor speeds. We’re going to keep on tweaking. Since we’re only a second year team, those major programming tasks are quite a challenge to tackle. However, we aren’t about to back down from a challenge!
We’re using an 8" aluminum plaction wheel with rubber wedgestock tread. However, in one of our tests the tread popped off, so we added extra pop-rivets.
In other news, you really want to do bang-bang control for your shooter speed. It’s simpler to program, easier to tune, and gets your flywheel up to speed much faster than a PID.
What material are you using for the “fence” (curved wall that is on opposite side of Frisbee from the spinning wheel) in your shooter?
How much compression are you using?
Are you running your CIM at full speed (looks like you gear up the wheel to spin faster than the CIM)?
Any idea on the RPM of the wheel you are shooting with?
We are testing a similar design but not getting nearly the distance that you are. We don’t want to shoot full court, but it may become necessary depending on how the game plays out.
For those asking for specs here is a description (we can take a close up of things if you’d like to add those as well).
8” performance wheels (hex shaft) with wedgetop tread (http://www.andymark.com/product-p/am-0105.htm)
Custom 1:1.2 up conversion modulox gearbox – using VexPro ceramic coated aluminum gears driven with a single CIM
Flywheel is a 10” plywood saw blade with the teeth ground off & attached to the aluminum performance wheel – it also acts as a guide to keep the Frisbee flat as it travels around the wheel
Bottom outside wall is made of aluminum angle back notched every 1” and pop riveted to the polycarbonate
We line the inside of the outer wall with wedgetop
Another piece of aluminum angle is added to keep the discs flat – rivets are used to attaché both the wedgetop and top angle to the base wall – in ends up looking like this:
Compression of the outer aluminum wall is 15” the added wedgetop makes it about 14 5/8”
We made 10 out of 10 shots from 18’ last night
We can document the RPM of the wheel and accuracy later as well as provide some close up photos