[Game Thread] SFM1 - Puella Magi Forum★Mafia

Make a contract with me and become a magical girl!

After experiencing a bizarre dream, Madoka Kaname, a kind 14-year-old girl, encounters a magical creature named Kyubey. Madoka and her friend, Sayaka Miki, are offered the opportunity of gaining magical powers if they agree to make a contract with the strange little being. He will also grant them one wish, but in exchange, they shall risk their lives by accepting the responsibility of fighting Witches. Invisible to human eyes, Witches are catalysts of despair in the areas they inhabit. A magical girl named Mami Tomoe, an ally of Kyubey, befriends and encourages the two girls to accept the contract. This is the beginning of a new story of magical girls.

Special thanks to Swordsworth and eevee for helping review this game.

Flavor and Spoilers

This game is based on the animated television series Puella Magi Madoka★Magica. No prior knowledge of the source material is required to play. Outside knowledge of flavor will provide no significant gameplay benefit.

This game has been designed with the intent of providing only light spoilers. However, using the internet to look for further details does run the risk of encountering information that might spoil the story for you. Tread carefully - if you have any interest at all, the original series is only 12 episodes long and is easily available on both Hulu and Netflix, so it is almost easier to just watch it.

Whether you are familiar with the source material or have decided to search for more info online, please be extremely careful to not spoil the story for anyone else. Just because you think you wouldn’t care does not give you license to hamper the experience of others who might.

When in doubt, I am always an available resource for everything you will need to know to succeed at this game.


1: Follow the Chief Delphi forum rules. Do not flag posts that break these rules - report them to the host in your role card and let them handle the situation. If you feel further action is necessary, PM a member of the Mafia Congress.

2: Be respectful to the hosts and your fellow players. Attacking other players in a personal manner is strictly forbidden. Likewise, intentionally spoiling elements of the source material’s story is to be avoided.

3: Don’t throw the game. Always play with the intent of helping your faction win.

4: Don’t be inactive. If you do not post meaningfully within 24 hours or at least twenty times in any given phase, you will be prodded. Receiving two prods or failing to respond to a prod within 12 hours will result in your removal from the game. Attempts to “prod dodge” by barely meeting this limit are discouraged.

5: Do not discuss the game outside of the game. Anywhere. It’s not worth it.

6: No editing or deleting posts for any reason without express host permission.

7: No posting after the majority is reached or at day. I can’t lock the thread, so I’m relying on you all to just follow this rule and not post. Repeated or egregious failure to comply will result in your removal from the game.

8: Do not quote/screenshot private host messages. They’re private for a reason.

9: Angleshooting is strictly prohibited. This involves any and all methods outside of the game thread that may help determine a player’s alignment, including your own. If this occurs accidentally, PM the hosts. If this occurs intentionally, it may be considered cheating.

10: Keep the thread clean of outside influence. Dead players cannot interact with those alive in any way, including liking posts in the game thread. Living players, likewise, should direct all questions to the hosts through their role card.

11: Do not edit the OP for any reason without host permission. If you believe you can make a positive contribution, PM the hosts first.

12: It’s a game - have fun!


This game will be hosted by @orangeandblack5
This game will be co-hosted by @clonedcheese and @JKBear331

This game will run a closed rolemadness setup
There will be an informed minority and an uninformed majority
There may or may not be “Lost Wolf” or “Traitor”-type roles
There may or may not be third-party roles

Example Role Card:

“I want you to form a contract with me and become magical girls!”

Host Example

Example Card (Passive) - Because you are an example role card, you will not actually spawn in the game.

Contract (Night) - Get the player reading this to sign a contract, forcing them to join this game. (Infinite uses)

Host (Day) - Carry out all the day actions your players make tonight. (Infinite uses)

You must ensure the game is not Canned.

Setup Notes:
This game features inverted phases - players talk and vote at night and most actions are taken during the day
Unless specified otherwise, no roles may self-target, including protective roles

Nights will start at 22:30 EST and last 48 hours
Days will start at 22:30 EST and last 24 hours
The game will begin during the night

To accuse someone, say "## /vote [Player_Name]" on a new line
To rescind your vote, say "## /unvote" on a new line
You may vote for nobody to be eliminated by saying "## /vote NoElim" on a new line
The hosts will give current vote counts whenever they are available to do so
Votes are automatically locked in at LyLo and may not be changed once placed

Every night will have a deadline elimination - whoever has the most votes when night ends will be eliminated
It will be made public when the game is in LyLo (when anything but a correct elimination will lead to an informed minority victory)


What is Forum Mafia?
Here is a short guide from Mafia Universe describing the basics of Forum Mafia. In short, it is a variation of the party game Mafia (also known as Werewolf) that has been adapted to be played on internet forums.

What does _______ mean?
There is a great glossary of various Mafia terms that may be used on the Mafia Universe Wiki.

I’m still confused.
Feel free to ask me any and all questions you may have via PM.

I see the game is full, can I still play somehow?
I’d love to have some backups in case anybody drops out or is inactive. Backup players might be called upon at any time to fill the shoes of a player that needs to be replaced. You may join as a backup at any time by saying "## /backup" in this thread.


1: REM
2: Arete Killed Mid-N4 - Ulla, Witch Neighbor/Apportioner
3: Litten Killed D1 - H.N. Elly (Kirsten), Witch Rolestopper
4: ash4fun
5: Bepwei
6: IronicDeadBird
7: quin
8: EricKline
9: gellnick Icibalus Eliminated N2 - ?????, Witch Ascetic Innocent Child/Arsonist
10: darth_tabor Valerie Killed Mid-N3 - Gotz, Witch Slank Vigilante
11: Squirrel2412 Chemist1422
12: Nibio Wisp Eliminated N3 - Adelbert, Witch Watcher
13: NuclearBurrito Killed D1 - Homura Akemi, Magical Girl Ninja/1-Shot Paralyzer/3-Shot Janitor
14: Marshal Seththeking Eliminated N4 - Elsa Maria, Witch 1-Shot Party Host/Magnet
15: SlayerBoy26 Deadbananas
16: Zone_Q11 Killed Mid-N2 - Sebastian’s, Witch Tracker
17: Scout6088/quarky sunbell/ActionDan Killed D2 - Daniyyel + Jennifer, Witch Hydra Bus Driver
18: Alison Geyde Nanook Killed D3 - Izabel, Witch Doctor
19: USELESS - Modkilled N1 - Gisela, Witch Tracker
20: Operator_Chan GoalkeeperBoss - Eliminated N1 - Gertrud, Witch Jailkeeper
21: Juckproty Ari_2412 Killed D2 - Patricia, Witch Parity Cop

Important Events
Night 1 Start
Player Substitution - Juckproty is replaced by Ari_2412
Player Substitution - Operator_Chan is replaced by GoalkeeperBoss
Modkill - USELESS has died, Gisela, Witch Tracker
Player Substitution - SlayerBoy26 is replaced by DeadBananas
Player Substitution - darth_tabor is replaced by Valerie
Night 1 Ends - GoalkeeperBoss is eliminated, Gertrud, Witch Jailkeeper
Day 1 Begins - Shadow consumes Mitakihara!
Night 2 Begins - Litten is killed, H.N. Elly (Kirsten), Witch Rolestopper, and NuclearBurrito is killed, Homura Akemi, Magical Girl Ninja/1-Shot Paralyzer/3-Shot Janitor
Event - Evil Witches destroy Mitakihara!
Event - Using a time loop, the Magical Girls restore the city!
Player Substitution - gellnick is replaced by Icibalus
Player Substitution - Squirrel2412 is replaced by Chemist1422
Player Substitution - Scout6088 is replaced by sunbell
Player Substitution - Alison is replaced by Geyde
Night 2 Resumes - We’re back, Witches!
Player Substitution - quarky is replaced by ActionDan
Tiro Finale - Zone_Q11 is killed, Sebastian’s, Witch Tracker
Night 2 Ends - Icibalus is eliminated, ?????, Witch Ascetic Innocent Child/Arsonist
Night 3 Begins - sunbell and ActionDan are killed, Daniyyel + Jennifer, Witch Hydra Bus Driver, and Ari_2412 is killed, Patricia, Witch Parity Cop
Player Substitution - Marshal is replaced by Seththeking
Player Substitution - Geyde is replaced by Nanook
Tiro Finale - Valerie is killed, Gotz, Witch Slank Vigilante
Night 3 Ends - Wisp is eliminated, Adelbert, Witch Watcher
Night 4 Begins - Nanook is killed, Izabel, Witch Doctor
Tiro Finale - Arete is killed, Ulla, Witch Neighbor/Apportioner
LyLo Begins - Votes are now locked once placed
Game Over - The Magical Girls have successfully defeated the Witches!
Post-Game - All role cards revealed

1 Like


For as long as humans have existed, Witches have preyed on their misery and their despair, spreading their curses and drawing countless humans to their deaths.

Thus, it has fallen upon a number of young females over the years to do battle with these Witches and ensure their destructive powers are stopped before they can wreak havoc.

The humans who have taken this burden on their shoulders are known as Magical Girls. It is through their sacrifices that humanity thrives.

Yet these brave heroes do not go unrewarded - in exchange for a lifetime of thankless and risky battle with the forces of evil, they are granted a single wish, with which they are able to realize whatever desires they may hold.

Thus, we find ourselves in Mitakihara, Japan, where a number of young Magical Girls have found themselves doing battle with the evil Witches in an attempt to safeguard their city and carry out the duties they agreed to shoulder when they made their wishes.

Will the Witches prove too powerful to be stopped? Or will the Magical Girls be able to work together and put an end to the misery sown by the Witches and protect their neighbors, friends, and family from harm?

Night 1 has started and will end 2020-01-11T03:30:00Z.

1 Like

A few important notices:

1. This game has manual vote counts. If you notice something is incorrect, please notify the hosts in your PM.

2. The vote counts are tabulated via spreadsheet. The names of voters for a specific target will show up in the order they appear in the player-list in the OP, NOT in the order votes were placed.

3. Some of you are new to the forums, and so depending on your activity prior to the game may hit post caps for new users. If this occurs, DM me on Discord at orangeandblack5#4506 as soon as you can. The sooner I am notified, the sooner I can try and get a forum mod to help you.

4. If you have any questions, comments, or concerns, please use your role card to ask me or my co-hosts, @clonedcheese and @JKBear331 for help. We will not respond to questions asked of us in the thread in most cases. If it is urgent, again, ping me on Discord at orangeandblack5#4506.

4. Good luck, and have fun.







Okay I’m tired but gg

Heck yeah!

I’m awake


Hello! How’s everyone?


/vote REM

Because only a scum would be checking for he thread so quickly/often.


Do I know you from another site, or is this our first time playing together?


Is ur pfp softing Homura Akemi?


No I just wanted to get the first post


in a row


Not Voting 20 REM Arete Litten Bepwei IronicDeadBird quin EricKline gellnick darth_tabor Squirrel2412 Nibio NuclearBurrito Marshal SlayerBoy26 Zone_Q11 Scout6088/quarky Alison USELESS Operator_chan Juckproty
REM 1 ash4fun

Please use “## /vote” to vote.

1 Like

Alright boy’os

Who wants to claim their witch ship and receive a gift of tomato’s for their claim.