Gracious Professionalism > Ungracious Unprofessionalism

FIRST General Forum
#12

First of all: Excellent total post, Steve. You shared some great thoughts!

In response to the first paragraph quoted, you are absolutely correct. As you know, I sometimes work very closely with some FIRST people, and you are absolutely right in your supposition that they’re not listening to the Forums…many are unaware of what the forums do, or even of the existence of this site. Someone else, I don’t know who, made the suggestion to suggest to FIRST that they have someone scan the site, at least occasionally so that they have some idea of what’s being discussed.

As far as posts are concerned, it’s always much more gracious to make a suggestion privately, rather than make a public display! You both look better to each other and to the community at large. :wink:

Occasionally, the behavior of others does need a direct bit of assertiveness. It’s only lately, and perhaps more so this year, that I have personally seen or heard of less than gracious behavior from teams. I was really disappointed, because I’ve always thought that this was one activity where people were consistently nice to each other. And it wasn’t always the young people. We need to stress the idea that grandma’s watching everybody!

Now, what’s the best way to get these messages out and about???

#13

I agree! This is especially true in the Rules/Strategy forum. Someone asks a question that could have been answered just by looking in the right part of the rule book (usually game rules or robot building rules). Then someone else looks it up and responds. And about ten more people do the same with their take on it. Takes up time needed to build a robot…

#14

Memo to Brandon: here’s one for the Newbie button!

Thanks for sharing this - I still have a grin and giggle thing going.

#15

I think these really need to be emphasized. We’ve developed the “Search before you post” mantra lately. Search is a great tool that everyone should learn how to use, but:

  1. I did a brief search for “search before you post” and the threads they refer to… on a few occasions, the original poster had negative reps with total post counts less than 10. Someone had it on their first post. To the rest of us that have seen the reputation debates and made up our mind that it’s not really so important, this may have little effect, but on the user’s first few posts?

  2. One of the great things I like about FIRST competitions is that I can go up to a really veteran team, ask a question (that may turn out to be very obvious and seemingly quite stupid), and get a courteous, helpful answer without getting a “stupid newbie” or “you should know better” feeling. I might be alone in this, but seeing everyone spout out “search before you post” doesn’t quite give the same effect. If someone is asking a simple question, perhaps “I found this answer to your question in this thread using search” or “{quick answer}. If you want more details, you might want to check out this thread I found using search.” If someone is making a discussion question, perhaps, “I saw some other people discussing the same topic here:”. The threads can then be closed/merged/etc. Text on the internet is very impersonal, and knowing FIRST’s target audience, there’s the possibility that a new user has never used the internet before. Some need a special welcome into the community, and the less impersonal our responses are, the better…

“I see you’re pretty new to these boards. Welcome to the ChiefDelphi community! You’ll find that there’s a lot of helpful people and resources here that can help answer your questions and share the FIRST experience. Regarding <topic>, there’s a lot of discussion about that topic <link>here</link> already. I found it using search function, which can help you find if someone else is wondering the same thing already. There’s a wonderful tutorial about how to use search here. Hope that helps, and welcome again!”

We don’t build robots because it’s easy, we do it because it’s hard. Maybe we can work on giving new members a warmer and gentler welcome, because it’s hard ;).

#16

Good list! I would also like to add:

  • You don’t have to have perfect syntax and grammar, but if you want other posters to take you seriously, it helps to be able to form a coherent sentence. And let’s face it, it’s not really that hard, is it?
  • Use your English skills to find the nicest way to say whatever you want to say. If there isn’t a nice way to say something, you probably don’t need to say it, at least not on a public forum. For example, disagreeing is fine, but instead of saying, “You’re wrong!” you could just as easily say, “I disagree with you because…”
  • Easy on the smileys! Please?
  • If you’re in so much of a rush that you can’t type out entire words (“you” instead of “u”, etc), you probably don’t have time to be browsing an online forum.
#17

I’d agree

I don’t post much (if you can’t tell), but i read alot. Sometimes i want to post and return the fact that they’re being a little short tempered there, and it kinda stops me. I’m not going to waste all my time doing that stuff.
It’s not nice. End of story

#18

wow! I made the mistake of venturing into a thread a couple days ago on a political subject, and I got absolutely HAMMERED with assualts on my intelligence, comments on my grammer and punctuation (or lack there of)

I was accused of spreading half-truths and lies (with no rebuttal to the actual statements themselves, whatever they were)

and I was repeatedly hit with thinly vailed insults

To put it bluntly, Im appalled to see people on this forum think that insulting someone, name calling, labeling, or criticizing someone elses language, spelling, punctuation… is either appropriate, acceptable, or that this somehow makes your point for you

or that flinging a mulititude of insults and induendos is even better

If you know what someone is saying then they have communicated their message, there is no need for every post to have perfect spelling or grammer

logic and reasoning skills should be required in public schools. If you are in a passionate debate, insulting the other person and criticizing their language skills contributes nothing to your position.

#19

I agree 100%. All too often people just reply with “Search before you post” with a link and it always sounds very harsh to me. Honestly, I find the “Search before you post” people to be way more annoying (and rude) than the newbies asking simple questions.

To those who love to slam people with “Search before you post”: maybe you should think twice before you reply too. If someone came up to you at a competition and asked you how many points a tetra on a goal was worth, would you snap back at them, “Read the manual!” I hope not.

#20

Yeap, you two are 110% right. just saying, go Search it is rude at times. Its more constructive to teach them something as well as give them an answer.

How many points are tetra’s worth again? I seem to have forgotten…

Appropriate Answer: They are worth 3 points on top and 1 point if they are underneath the goals. If you have any more questions you may want to consult here if you have any more questions.

you guys get the idea, you should think of Chief Delphi as an extention of the pit area, everyone is really friendly, love robots, and you can always get your questions answered. not as a forum where people slam each other just for the heck of it.

#21

The reason why that is done is so the page doesn’t get flooded with duplicate threads. It is not meant to be rude it is meant to keep the page neat and orderly.

#22

Simply saying “search before you post” can be interpreted as rude. All it takes is some grace, shown by the eloquent Genia. Look at that. She was helpful, concise, and said “search before you post” in a tactful way. Let’s learn from her.

Andy B.

#23

Yes, I understand why it is done, however, to the uninitiated, it looks like a very short, very unfriendly response.

How is a response that says “Search before you post” any more neat and orderly than one that says “I searched the forums and found that the answer to your question is {blah}. Here’s some threads that came up that have already discussed this topic: {blah} {blah}.”? To me, the latter just sounds a lot more friendly.

I guess I don’t like it when people get publicly scolded for making a newbie mistake. Searching first is an etiquette thing that we take for granted but the fact that so many people make this mistake is an indication that it apparently is not common knowledge for new members and therefore we need to be nice about it.

The fact that it’s in the rules when they sign up for this site should prevent it, but face it: a lot of people just don’t read that stuff. Do you know how many teams I’ve inspected at competitions that failed to put the team number on their robot? It’s one of the most common things that I have to tell teams to fix. And, it’s in the rule book and it’s the very first item on the inspection checklist and it’s an easy one. As much as it irritates me each time I see it, I don’t yell at the team and make some sarcastic comment about reading the rules. This is a very similar situation, and it’s more important because it’s very easy for people to misinterpret emotions and intentions when they’re only reading text (especially if they’re relative newbies to online communities such as this).

#24

2 Thoughts:

  • Efficiency, neatness, and orderliness are useful tools, but they aren’t the end-all-be-all of a team or a forum.

  • My rookie team went to Atlanta this year, and they were disturbed by the lack of GP shown by other teams, in contrast to the Las Vegas Regional (the only other competition we’d been to). The friendliness and camaraderie at the Regional was missing in the pit and on the field. There were even teams who covered up their robots in the pit when asked a question! It made the team question whether they just wanted to stick with Regionals next year!

#25

Why is it that I didn’t hear stories like this when I joined FIRST three years ago?

It could just be me, but it seems like the emphasis on GP has decreased. Significantly, and not just on this website.

I’m not quite sure if this is on-topic in the thread, though, since this seems to be dedicated to the website more than FIRST in general. That said, I’ve got a few ideas brewing that I could post here (or elsewhere) later on…

#26

Genia rocks my socks! she is a very nice person and she always uses smileys and replies to PM’s! I think we should all use her as a role model… :smiley:

yeah about the lack of GP thing, I am a rookie and I found most people to be REALLY nice at competitions, both Pacific Northwest Regional and Championships, but I have noticed that sometimes on the forums people are a little less than nice. so let’s all be like Genia and use smileys and be good FIRSTies
-anjali

#27

I have to say that Sabrina did a very good job in teaching her team what Gracious Professionalism is. She is one of the few examples of great student leaders in FIRST.

I feel the level of gracious professionalism has gone down(just a little bit) in the past year or so, but it can be re-enforced. Yet, FIRST is one of the few sports in which Gracious Professionalism prevails at such a good level. These are principles we students need to learn while we are young.

I think the “Search before you post” response was formulated because everyone was frustrated by the re-occurring threads.

Anyways, you brought up a nice point Matt, good job.

#28

Gracious Professionalism is supposed to be the backbone in FIRST competitions. When I talk about the program I explain how even though it’s COMPETITIVE we still work TOGETHER. One of my fondest memories was 2003’s NJ Regional. 1156 (from Brazil) was a rookie team as was 1089. Unfortunately, the team had to ship their robot in pieces and reconstruct it the Thursday of the regional. I remember 1089 and team 25 coming together with tools and help to put their robot back together.

After 56 won Philadelphia, 1089 had a large discussion about raising money for them to go to Nationals. Nationals, for me, was one of the best experiences I’ve had in FIRST and it’s one of the main reasons I keep coming back. Everyone in FIRST deserves the opportunity to experience what I have. They too have worked hard on they’re robot and are worthy opponents- they beat us !

Our team is about helping, inspiring, and overall just being friendly. What better way to show how we feel about FIRST than to do anything we can to support it?

Something Mr. Gregory said that I find inspiring is the following:

" [FIRST] is ultra-competitive, but the point is that you’re not trying to out-do your competition off the playing field. You want every team to have the best chance that they possibly could have. It could mean different things at different times. We’ve had numerous cases where we’d help a team fix their robot only to face them in the next round. Why? We want a good round, and we’d hate to see someone have to forefeit because of a broken bot. Someone needs a sprocket? we’re there… a spare motor? sure thing… and in return, we hope that other teams would do the same thing (and they often do)."

#29

Does anyone have a good “one-pager” on how we (within FIRST) define “gracious professionalism”? I want a short description to give to incoming students in order to “set the stage” as newbies on the team.

Also, I’ve seen 99.9% living examples of gracious professionalism here on the CD forum as well as in the various FIRST events. Sure, in written form on this forum (and any other e-mail written correspondence) it is MUCH MORE IMPORTANT to follow these rules than it is for an in-person dialog:

  1. Read the person’s words twice; first for content and again for “tone” of writing style
  2. The internet forums and e-mail is NOT a place to practice “text messaging” shorthand. You’ve got a full-screen view, so use it and use the language properly.
  3. Sure, do a “search” first. They call it “putting your brain in gear before engaging your mouth”. Then when you do post a query, it’s fine to state “I tried to do a search, but…”
  4. And…when you do reply…pretend that you’re the recipient not the author. Many times I stash an outgoing e-mail for 24 hours before sending just to see if my “tone” and “mood” might have changed. Also, spell-check will get you lots of “points” with the person reading your thread.

I’m so thrilled and proud to be a rookie part of FIRST. Even at my age, many of the students have taught me so much about the true meaning of “gracious professionalism”. Keep it up.

#30

The poster in this white paper may do the trick: http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/papers.php?action=single&paperid=117

It’s two years old, but GP is GP.

#31

I’d like to start off by saying one very important thing

This thread is one of the best examples of gracious professionalism I have seen here in a long time.

I have already given rep points to 9 people in this thread. it’s really great to see that when GP is brought to our attention again we are able to pull it off beautifully. now what we need to work on is having this kind of attitude all the time.

for all the bad i have seen on these forums, the main problem has been people takign things too seriously. i think there are a few guidelines that should be followed, some of which have already been mentioned, and some i am bringing up myself:

don’t give negative rep points for “newbie mistakes”

  • be polite when posting a “search before you post” reminder
  • for mistakes that are careless, not malicious, try to take advantage of the “neutral rep point” to give them a reminder without harming their rating. we ALL make mistakes, even Brandon and Dave
  • try not to give negative reps on controversial threads. somebody who expresses dissapproval of an idea is only insulting that idea, NOT the people who follow it.
    *]if you really want to practice gracious professionalism, only give negative reps to those who fail to practice it themselves