New York Tech Valley Regional Qual 43

Anybody see an issue here? Have there been other documented cases where the field counts Cargo 10X? Seems like a field fault should’ve been called right away… Happens twice in this match.

https://youtube.com/clip/UgkxcNoBp8KwWdSusaKqyYFqoSSZwrJ04L5W

https://youtube.com/clip/UgkxIbKSA6by51HKRaPJDeO98zglmJ_GTgPE

I saw that too. Is there anyway to bring it to the attention of the FTA?

Mentor from 2614 here. We immediately asked about replaying the match. Right after, we were told no. A few minutes later, we were told they would run a field test and assess from there. We haven’t heard back. Our scouts have our robot as scoring 15 in teleop and 1 in auto, which clearly doesn’t add up to 44. We’d love to replay if the field staff decides that’s what should happen, it doesn’t feel good to win this way, and it has a distinct effect on rankings for both alliances.

20 Likes

I saw that. It looked like it jumped from 11 cargo to 34. I feel like that should have been fairly obvious and the match should have been replayed.

Edit: changed the number of cargo it went to

1 Like

It jumped from 11 to 34.

It was mind boggling that the score jumped so much and nobody caught it! Hopefully it gets replayed for the sake of all the teams involved. It was a super critical match for determining rankings.

4 Likes

Our scouts have the full alliance ball total at 21, so in terms of our alliance’s RP, it doesn’t have an effect. However, it does massively affect our tiebreaker scores. The opposing alliance also had a huge jump in points, scoring them an RP where they otherwise wouldn’t. When their score jumped, our drive coach actually fully turned around to the stands and looked at me waving his arms in confusion, so at the very least our alliance was aware during the match and attempted to contact a referee in match.

4 Likes

Im absolutely sure there was one, either a FIM or midwestern event. I cannot find it offhand though, nor how the match ended up being scored/replayed

I believe it was in FIM and the match was replayed, but I can’t for the life of me remember which event. I do remember that it was a week 1 event though

Rochester we had this happen but it was almost immediately caught and replayed. Shame, I would have liked to have score 30 cargo in a match.

1 Like

You guys are killing it. You are fun to watch

Quals 3 - FIM District Milford Event presented by GM Proving Grounds 2022 - The Blue Alliance was one.

1 Like

Match 30 also got a 10 cargo jump.

This topic was automatically closed 365 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.