WooHoo! Nice and Simple, I like it. This will come in handy, I hate getting out my calculator or dealing with chunky spreadsheets everytime I need to make a few calculations.
Is anybody interested in writing a simplified version of this program for TI84 calculators?
That would be awesome to use.
thanks, Vivek
p.s. sorry I’m posting so much, Chris is using me as his guinea pig and I really find this thing useful. It cut my drivetrain design time from 5 min. to about 5 sec.
Hi Chris,
This looks like it could be a good resource for some quick calculations. I haven’t had time to check your math, but it seems reasonable off the top of my head.
If there was one thing to criticize it is your presentation. There were some things you did which confused me a little bit. Maybe it is because I read into things too much due to my familiarity with this material. Some of your terminology is also a little confusing. Nothing that some massaging can’t fix.
Overall good job! The best part about this sheet for me, is the lessons that YOU must have learned while creating it. It takes a certain familiarity with the math behind these concepts to create something like this. Kudos to you for taking the time, it will certainly serve you well in the future. I hope you continue to evolve & improve your sheets, because as we all know, design IS an iterative process.
Nice! This looks like a couple of good resources for people who are speccing out their drive systems. Your ~0.9 factor for what the actual speed of the CIM is a decent estimate for the general case, I think.
I think one of the great parts of this is your careful attention to what units are being used at each step of the process.
I agree with John’s thought on making it as clear and understandeable as possible. You can never stop making it easier to use.
Not that these ideas would make it easier to use (probably the opposite :)) but how about at the important parts of the calculation having a link which describes the calculation that is going on behind the scenes? Or how about a couple of plots showing the results that got generated (top speed versus gear ratio, for example). How about a pushing force calc?
Thanks i am planning on making it a lot more user friendly and hopefully eventually make it have a nice interface.
I will put up a page on how i make these calculations so if i made a mistake you can check my math.
Im currently writing up some rough very rough calculations in excel to calculate acceleration, and how much pushing power you will have (with rough top and wedge top) and eventually make it into a web page.
I was thinking about that before but i wanted to keep them in separate files just for ease of finding them but once i find i have them pretty much how i want them i will upload them in a .zip file so you only have to download 1 file for all the calculators and “How To’s”.