Rules are simple: If it is not on the list, it is Not Allowed. If it is modified, even if it is on the list, it is Not Allowed unless the modification is on the Allowed Modification list.
And basically everything on the list is COTS pneumatic parts. Using hot glue to make a plug makes that part not COTS…
The “not come up” means that the inspectors–for whatever reason–didn’t spot it. If they did, it would have been gone after the first one.
[Editing because apparently there are questions] I’m going to number and paraphrase the rules to hopefully make things clearer. The post was originally responding to:
FRC pneumatics rules covering allowed parts:
R801: If it isn’t allowed by this section, it’s not allowed.
R802: If it isn’t both COTS and properly rated, it’s not allowed.
R803: You can’t modify pneumatic parts, except by [list of allowed modifications which is basically cut tubing, connect to control system, assemble, and label].
R804: The list of parts that are allowed. [Note: Interestingly enough, the plugs aren’t specifically listed–I believe they’d land in R804E, connecting fittings, though].
The part a home-made plug piece violates is a combination of 801, 802, and 803. It’s not rated, it’s not COTS, and it’s modified if you want to argue that the tubing is COTS. Therefore, it’s not allowed by 802 or 803, and because that one disallows it, it’s disallowed by 801.
The fact it got through inspection multiple times simply means that the inspectors didn’t catch it, for whatever reason. It happens. If you happen to run across @Andy_Baker at an event, ask him about “purple air tanks”…