Video Replay Review

[MikLast]

@HarrisonKaufman1619

I’m curious what the FIRST community’s views are on the rationale behind not allowing video replay review.

They view the rationale against it poorly.

/thread.

---

Couple other threads if you haven’t seen them already also, not that more discussion isint bad:

Remind me again why we can't have video review of referee calls

Watch this match, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iXfmgpyvYPs and tell me why you think the call for multiple technical fouls on 900 would stand if official video reviews by the HR were allowed. This cost alliance 3 the match and the semifinals. Why don’t we have video review again?

Video Review Needs to Happen Now

Please share this, tweet this, etc. FIRST students put too much effort into their robots to be cheated out of their achievements like this anymore. As much as FIRST has done for me over the years, one of my biggest problems with the organization is the rule that forces Referees to ignore video evidence exposing bad calls made on the field. Just today at the New York City Regional, teams 395, 2869, and 1546 were cheated out of their win in the second quarterfinals match by a failure to count a d…

Video Review

I’ve seen many discussions here regarding ideas pertaining to the possible implementation of video review. The calls became more apparent after Einsteins Finals 1 when 254 was in possession of three cargo balls and received no penalty for it. I think a very simple implementation for video review without delaying matches too much is putting it in playoffs only. I think that video reviews in Qualification rounds would delay events even further than what they already are. One possible idea would…